Prijava • Board Game Arena

Vse prijave

Prijave igre santorini_displayed

#29287: "Nyx vs Chaos"

fixed: Hrošč je bil odpravljen

Na kaj se nanaša prijava?

santorini #126420217

Kaj se je zgodilo? Prosimo, izberi spodaj

Pravila: pravilo igre ni bilo upoštevano

Kaj se je zgodilo? Prosimo, izberi spodaj

Pravila: pravilo igre ni bilo upoštevano

Prosimo preverite ali že obstaja poročilo o isti zadevi

Če je tako, GLASUJTE za to poročilo. Poročila z največ glasovi se obravnavajo PREDNOSTNO!

#	Status	Votes	Game	Type	Title	Last update

Natančen opis

Zgodovina poročil

Dec 3 rd 2020 17:30 • Crisfole • Razvijalcem tega hrošča še ni uspelo reproducirati:

No extra info

Dec 3 rd 2020 23:10 • quietmint • Razvijalcem tega hrošča še ni uspelo reproducirati:

I didn't review this yet, but just FYI, the order is implemented as: your power, then opponent's power. So the behavior will vary depending on which player's turn it is...

Dec 4 th 2020 14:07 • gretirse • Razvijalcem tega hrošča še ni uspelo reproducirati:

was'nt there a discussion about Nyx with mlvanbie on Discord? I think he said that the power was going to be slightly modified to happen at the start of all turns with highest priority, to deal with this kind of issues and with Dionysus-like powers.

Dec 4 th 2020 14:24 • quietmint • Razvijalcem tega hrošča še ni uspelo reproducirati:

Yes, I think I asked about this on Discord #rules some months ago because the official rules don't specify anything about timing. I remember my conclusion was that the BGA implementation was not going to change.

But I will research that discussion. Maybe we were supposed to ban this combination of powers?

Dec 5 th 2020 14:25 • quietmint • Hrošč je bil potrjen s strani razvijalcev:

Yes, this issue relates to the timing of powers. With no official rules about timing, I stand by our implementation in BGA (you first, opponent second) as perfectly reasonable and logical. That is the simplest and most intuitive interpretation I can think of, and it is how I would resolve any timing question that came up during play in real life. With multiple "start of turn" or "end of turn" powers in play, then, the order of operations is predictable but depending on the active player. For Nyx vs. Chaos:
* If Chaos builds the dome, Chaos + Nyx both do "end of turn"
* If Nyx builds the dome, only Nyx does "end of turn" and Chaos power gets removed before he can.

Technically there is no bug here. I do agree this behavior may be confusing and doesn't appear to be fair, so I will ban the combination Nyx vs. Chaos on BGA.

---

The Discord discussion is at discord.com/channels/523195652654497802/523214198680059926/753755555209674752. I'm still am not satisfied with mlvanbie's responses. He seems nonchalant, sort of inventing various different rules about the timing of powers as different questions arose. In future Santorini Pantheon edition, he mentions Nyx will be changed to "start of turn". If we applied that change to BGA implementation, we would "fix" Nyx vs. Chaos but we would cause the same problem for Nyx vs. Circe, Hypnus, Morpheus (who already have "start of turn" powers).

Dec 5 th 2020 18:07 • quietmint • Hrošč je bil odpravljen:

Version 201205-1904: Banned Nyx vs. Chaos

Dodaj nekaj k temu poročilu

Dodajte vse, kar se zdi primerno, da bi lahko reproducirali ta napako ali razumeli vaš predlog:

Drug ID mize/ premikanje ID-ja
Ali je F5 rešil težavo?
Se je problem pojavil večkrat? Vsakič? Naključno?
Če imaš posnetek zaslona te napake (priporočljivo), ga lahko naložite na poljuben način (snipboard.io for example) in tukaj prilepite povezavo.

Prekliči Posodobi prijavo

#29287: "Nyx vs Chaos"

Na kaj se nanaša prijava?

Kaj se je zgodilo? Prosimo, izberi spodaj

Kaj se je zgodilo? Prosimo, izberi spodaj

Prosimo preverite ali že obstaja poročilo o isti zadevi

Natančen opis

Zgodovina poročil

Dodaj nekaj k temu poročilu

Spremeni status prijave v:

Pomoč

Prispevaj

Navigacija

Spremljaj nas